I initially decided not to get the Urban Decay Naked Palette as I was pretty sure I could dupe it with Mac ones... but you know how it goes.. I caved! I can't get enough of neutral colors!
I'm not going to do a full review on this as there are hundreds out there already. - Same goes with swatches. (Visit Temptalia to read a full review and see amazing pictures of the eyeshadows.)
What I can do is sum it up by saying the Urban Decay eyeshadows are amazing! This palette is all you've heard -and then some! ;)
I haven't owned any UD e/s previous to this palette so I was so pleasantly surprised! They are equally as pigmentet - if not more, than Mac ones, and the colors are gorgeous!
The one problem with this palette is deciding what color to choose. You are going to want to apply them all! At once, preferably!
Lots of makeup gurus on You Tube and beauty bloggers are doing amazing looks and tutorials using the Naked Palette, so that's why I wanted to see if I could dupe the palette with Mac eyeshadows. If you don't want to spend the money to get this, but have a bunch of Mac ones around - here is how you can dupe the palette and join the fun! ♥
First, some Eye candy:
Here is what I came up with when trying to dupe the colors:
(Note: I don't own every Mac eyeshadow out there, so this is duping the palette based on the ones I own.. which is a lot!)
(Click on the pictures for super size!)
From left:
Virgin: Shroom. Virgin is an even more fine milled es. but this is a good dupe
Sin: Naked Lunch or Jest. Sin is actually slightly more beige, but it will give the same effect/color on the eyes
Naked: Kid
Sidecar: This one is really difficult to dupe. Mac doesn't have this color in their range, so the closest I came to dupe this with is Style Snob (a lighter version of Satin Taupe). Style Snob was a LE (Limited edition), but can be found on Ebay.
Buck: Cork
Half Baked: Woodwinked
Smog: Closest I found to this was Tempting. Smog is more brown while Tempting has got a bit more golden brown tones to it.
Darkhorse: Another eyeshadow Mac can't dupe. The closest I found was Magnetic Fields (also limited edition). Darkhorse is a lot more pigmented and a richer brown color than Magnetic Fileds, but you will get the same dark chocolate color with both.
Toasted: Sable
Hustle: Twinks or Smut
Virgin: Shroom. Virgin is an even more fine milled es. but this is a good dupe
Sin: Naked Lunch or Jest. Sin is actually slightly more beige, but it will give the same effect/color on the eyes
Naked: Kid
Sidecar: This one is really difficult to dupe. Mac doesn't have this color in their range, so the closest I came to dupe this with is Style Snob (a lighter version of Satin Taupe). Style Snob was a LE (Limited edition), but can be found on Ebay.
Buck: Cork
Half Baked: Woodwinked
Smog: Closest I found to this was Tempting. Smog is more brown while Tempting has got a bit more golden brown tones to it.
Darkhorse: Another eyeshadow Mac can't dupe. The closest I found was Magnetic Fields (also limited edition). Darkhorse is a lot more pigmented and a richer brown color than Magnetic Fileds, but you will get the same dark chocolate color with both.
Toasted: Sable
Hustle: Twinks or Smut
Gunmetal: Knight Divine or any dark grey/silver. Mac have several LE that resembles this (Pandamonium, Waft)
Let me know if you have managed to dupe Sidecar and Dark Horse better than I have! They are amazing neutral browns and I would love for Mac to have that in their permanent collection!
♥ Michelle
27 comments:
This review is perfect! I've been hunting for the Naked Palette for a while and it's ALWAYS sold out at my local Sephora! It's great to see what MAC colours can do the same job....
I was wondering with which MAC eyeshadows this palette could be duped! It's not so easy, especially Sidecar, but you did a good job!
What an amazing and helpful post, Michelle! I've been eyeing up the Naked palette for so long, it's like my perfect palette, LOL! I think after reading this post, I definitely need it in my life :) <3
Great post!
I don't really like Urban Decay eyeshadows. But the Naked palette does have great colors! So now I can dupe them with my mac eyeshadows! :)
Thanks so much for this girl!! I'm a neutral fanatic too and I just KNEW I had dupes in my MAC collection, so thus far I've managed to resist the Naked palette. I don't know if that will last, but its still nice to have these colors to refer to:)
Nikosmommy:
Thank you! ♥ I hope you'll get your hands on it! It's amazing! I still love my Mac eyeshadows, but it's great to have this sleek palette with all neutrals :)
Perfectly Unordinary:
Thank you sweetie :) No, Sidecar was a challenge! I would love for Mac to have that exact color!
Anna Saccone:
I know, Anna! This wold be your perfect palette for sure because I know you love colors like this :)
You need it! lol
Gorgeous bride to be ♥
Kittynail:
Yey! :) How come you don't like the UD eyeshadows? Have I missed something? ;)
SweetTea:
You are welcome! :)
This palette is easily duped (most of them), so you can definitely live without it ;) But it's something about having this perfect sleek palette with brand new eyeshadows that are ALL amazing! Hahaha I'm so week minded!
xo
amazing post, very very useful! i already have this palette but it's goood to know what MAC shadows i don't need now :) THANKS!
I've been trying to resist but I don't think I"ll make it through the weekend without buying it..
Great post - I've always wondered what the MAC version of Sin was!
I think I'll have to try get this palette - so many usable colours.
So glad you're loving it! Thanks for my shout-out! :)
Patricia:
Thank you! I'm so glad! :) Lots of Mac ones you don't need now! xo
Robin:
Hahaha, I know the feeling! ;)
Ella Pretty:
I know I'm a total enabler now, but seriously... I don't think you would regret getting it ;)
Valerie Valentine:
You are so welcome sweetie! Something will be in your mail box shortly ;) ♥
great post! very helpful.
Thank you for posting this, I have been searching for dupes since it's always sold out. Maybe you could try to match sidecar with one of mac pigments?
Thanks
I am still not sure if I am going to get this one but I got the NYC palette and the Black palette. Nice post, thanks for the dupes xx
Marina
Jeg har alltid foretrukket UDskyggene fremfor MAC, og den her paletten skal jeg ha, den verste hypen om den er nok over til jul, og den er ikke en LE, så den skal nok bli min en gang. ;)
Kos deg med den.
SS
Oh, thank you so much!! You answered so many of my questions! :D
OMG :D Girl You're my Goddess :) Seriously. Unfortunately in Poland, where I come from, Naked palette isn't available. I was dreaming about it, since I've read of it on Temptalia, and You gave me simple instruction, how to make my very own using MAC :) I do thank You so much :)
What a gorgeous palette!! For sure going to have to check out if Sephora has it <3
Erin
http://purelyparker.blogspot.com/
Kudos to you for finding dupes for the Naked palette e/s, I 'm sure it will come handy for many (although, unless sm1 owns a lot of the MAC dupes already, getting the Naked palette would definitely come cheaper)! :)
Very helpful post!
xx
I made the perfect dupe for sidecar- I used a pigment and a glitter reflects and then I pressed it. I used Shimmertime pigment and reflects antique gold. I have these 2 from one of the 3 different 5-mini pigment gift sets from the mac holiday 2009 collection which I think you can buy on ebay and possibly in a CCO.
Wow I'd say you're totally spot on with pretty much all the colors, the only one I'd disagree with is Hustle. Twinks and Smut are browned based whereas Hustle is a super creamy dark royal purple.
Seeing MAC dupes especially for Sidecar makes me a little less apprehensive to dig into my palette knowing there's a replacement for the sad sad day when I run out. Thanks for posting!
I will trying this..
http://www.herbscity.com/brand/aqua-flora.html
that was sooo helpful!Thank you!
Thank you for this information and your UNII review.
wow!! they looked very similar! thanks for the review darl.
Post a Comment